What is the difference between Damascus and Wootz steel?
You can check the answer of the people under the question at Quora “wootz steel knife“
What is the difference between Damascus and Wootz steel?
You can check the answer of the people under the question at Quora “wootz steel knife“
Wootz is a kind of steel( Wootz steel refers to the material ) with suspended carbon nanotubes made is southern India and Srilanka. The method of production originated in India around sixth century BC and exported globally. It was known to be one of the highest quality steel material at the time.
Damascus steel is a kind of steel blade made from Wootz steel ingots ( Damascus steel refers to the finished steel blade not the material ). It was produced in the middle east from 3rd to 17th century after the Arab traders introduced Wootz steel to Damascus. They perfected the art of making a strong sword out of the superior material by aligning the carbide and iron layers to make a composite sword with intricate patterns and became famous.
References:
[1] AN ADVANCED MATERIAL OF THE ANCIENT WORLD
[2] Damascus steel
[3] Wootz steel
[4] Ferrous metallurgy
[5] Steel
Authentic XYJ Since 1986,Outstanding Ancient Forging,6.7 Inch Full Tang
Damascus steel was Wootz steel imported from India and sold in Damascus. The wootz/ukku ingots from Southern India were fabricated into Swords in Syria and sold to Europeans, Turks and Arabs. It is a super material known for its superior and unsurpassed strength, superplasticity and corrosion resistance. Wootz was made by Indians for 1000s of years by heating black magnetite ore with carbon in a sealed clay crucible. The art of making Wootz died out in post colonial India in the 18th century. Recent studies suggest that the strength of the steel came from carbon nanotubes and nanowire.
There is no difference between Wootz and Damascus steel as it was imported from India. It is similar to Indian numerals being called Arabic numerals in the West.
Amazon Basics 14-Piece Kitchen Knife Block Set, High-Carbon
Wootz was a high-carbon steel made only in India. Being high-carbon meant it could be quenched to a very high hardness, which gives you a great cutting edge but makes the sword dangerously brittle.
The Japanese Samurai swordmakers welded bars of wootz steel to bars of wrought iron (which is very low in carbon and soft, but ductile, not brittle). They hammered the bars flat, folded them over, and welded them again, then hammered them again; some say as many as seven folds were normal. What began as two layers doubles with each fold, so you wind up with hundreds of thin layers of alternating high- and low-iron steel. It’s actually a composite structure, and the blades were etched to reveal the layers as the characteristic “water mark”. This produced a blade that was both hard and flexible.
Nobody is sure how Damascus steel was made. Some think the process was similar to the Samurai swordsmiths (welding two different alloys together and folding or twisting them to produce layers), but others have proposed different processes. We do know they imported Indian wootz for these blades, but whether that was the only ingredient or it was welded together with another alloy, we don’t know.
Chicago Cutlery Belden 15 Piece Premium Kitchen Knife
First, let’s clear up one thing: Damascus refers mostly to the pattern in the steel, rather than the actual composition of the steel. Therefore, in the modern sense of the word, there are multiple types of Damascus. Originally Damascus referred to the Wootz crucible steel swords, but those ingots were lost for some reason, and after some time, pattern welded steel started being produced to mimic the original Damascus pattern. Now there are multiple ways of getting these patterns. Note: the patterns are etched in the steel itself, they are not inlaid or ground onto the surface, but rather, go through the entire metal.
Wootz : Wootz steel is the original Damascus. Wootz ingots were produced in India, near mines in Hyderabad. These steel ingots were highly prized, and would be purchased immediately by traders and sold to swordsmiths throughout asia and the middle east. The wootz ingot is a crucible steel. The iron ore was put into a clay crucible (like a sealed round clay pot), and then carbon was added. This is possible with charcoal (See Heller making modern Wootz), but the Indians might have used plant fiber for the carbon. Then flux was added on top to seal it and draw out the air, most probably glass. The iron ore itself had traces of hard metals such as vanadium, manganese, phosphorus, etc, as seen from chemical analysis of the ancient blades. The crucible was then heated in a low temperature fire and the resulting steel drew in the carbon, and the hard metals formed bands of micro-segregation within the steel, which caused the ultimate damascus pattern. It is possible that the wootz ingots were heated and slow cooled repeatedly, to infuse sufficient carbon into the steel, and also to form the bands within the micro-structure.
This art was lost after a few centuries, either because: a) there was better/cheaper steels available or b) the ore mines with the correct quantities of hard metals ran out, and thus ‘wootz ingots’ of the correct type for banding were no longer available. Please note, that in this, the real secret was the making of the ingots, not the making of the blades.
Pattern Welded Damascus: In an attempt to replicate the patterned steel, smiths turned to another technique, which is pattern welding. This is essentially stacking steel plates together, of different quality metals (different carbon contents, different levels of other metals), and then tack welding them into one block. After that the block is heated in the forge, and then power hammered together, and elongated. Then a chisel is used to break it in two, and fold it back, thus doubling the layers. As you can imagine, each time this is done, you’re doubling the layers, so quite quickly you can have a very high layer count, which will reinforce the ultimate pattern in the metal. This method both creates patterns in the metal, and also homogenizes the steel, meaning the carbon and trace elements are spread out through the ingot and ultimately the blade. Thus, the final product is better, if your steel was not high quality to begin with. Pattern welded damascus can further be notched to create more severe patterns. (Deep notches cut into the ingot, causing a variation of the ladder pattern)
Canister Damascus: In this technique, a metal canister is filled with layers of different kinds of steel, welded shut, and then heated. The steel inside the canister becomes one ingot, but retains the layers, thereby ultimately keeping a pattern. Then, the canister is ground off, and the metal ingot can be further folded like regular steel, or just forged straight away. All three methods have to be finished with acid etching and polished to really bring out the patterns.
All three of these will create patterns in the steel itself, and the patterns themselves are called damascene, and the meaning of the word has now come to reflect the patterned blade itself, rather than what method was used to produce the original ingot. True Wootz cannot be reliably reproduced so far, and in any case, modern L2 or machine steel is already superior, so there is no real reason to try and replicate it other than simple curiosity. Pattern welding and Canister Damascus is mostly used for decorative purposes in my opinion, or to use different kinds of available steel, rather than any superiority of ingot quality over high grade machine tool homogenized modern steels available.
Wanbasion Black Stainless Steel Knife Set, Sharp Kitchen Knife
There is a lot of confusion on that subject, as two (see Soumendu Majee’s answer) radically different techniques are frequently both referred to as “damascus” steel.
Smith & Wesson Extreme Ops SWA24S 7.1in S.S. Folding Knife with 3.1in
As such, there is no such big difference between Damascus and Wootz steel. Damascus steel was manufactured using the Wootz ingots, manufactured in India using carbon nanowire technologies. India was a leading exporter of the Wootz steel which was used to make swords and Persian daggers.
The Wootz steel was formed by adding large quantities of carbon to iron. The name Wootz is actually a westernized version of the Tamil word ekku m eaning crucible steel.
Spring Assisted Knife – Pocket Folding Knife – Military Style
Very intelligent question
To understand this mystery we have to go in the history of urbanization first.
Since our evolution from Van-Nar to Manav the child of this specie had the longest period required to become self dependent unlike other animals.
In this process bondage from child to mother and a bit with father is much longer than other species.
This long journey of child-hood gave birth to strong family culture.
Due to this family culture we survived most natural calamities with the help of our brain (which is bigger than other species)
As we survived most in comparison of rival animal species for the bounties of nature; we grew in population out measuring mass of any other specie upon planet earth. (Today we weigh little less than 500 million ton)
As the population grown; availability of natural resource in given location start diminishing. There was no Amazon delivery system in place at that era.
So we started swarming like bee hives and covered surface of planet earth sporadically.
In the process of this migration an economic system of barter evolved.
To sustain the barter system some rules of family/Kabila/or hamlet were evolved.
Form this stage of barter some psychological motivations as depicted in theory of need by Abraham Maslow evolved.
With the motivation of survival and security three different economic cultures sprung as per the eco systems.
From child birth to death human goes through these three stages of psycho-economic evolution but in disproportionate way. (Due to enormous amount of brain cells in inactivated form in diverse individuals and their eco systems.)
From all these three different economic systems the common denominator was the Barter system; based upon certain eco systems specific rules.
Here someone broke the rules of their ecosystem.
There were two option of survival available in such conflicting events for species is fight or flight.
So the fighter who survived remained in their existing eco system. While the loser or non fighter flown till he or she exhausted. (Minority rule breakers [mostly individual or a family] having no supporter in their community to swarm with them)
Most such souls gathered near the most trodden route at the points of natural bounties.
Damascus was one of such place.
Due to its proximity of a growing market (Of life saving weaponries) very good workmanship evolved here (law of demand and supply)
Despite their huge trade in weapon market their swords not survived vagaries of war.
Due to vulnerability of the swards thanks to brittleness (braking) or quick loss of edge their purchasers were not able to make any significant empire.
Because of that they had started to import the Wootz steel from here and made the legendary Damascus swords from it and the name were…
That is why mostly Damascus sward and Wootz steel became synonyms; this evolved to the stage people talking about Damascus when thinking about Wootz steel.
imarku Japanese Chef Knife – Pro Kitchen Knife 8 Inch Chef’s Knives